Rabbi Dosa ben Harkinas

From Zissil
Jump to: navigation, search

Warning: You are not logged in.

Your IP address will be recorded in this page's edit history.
The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision Your text
Line 15: Line 15:
 
==Tana==
 
==Tana==
 
===Incident of the New Moon===
 
===Incident of the New Moon===
Once two witnesses testified before Raban Gamliel claiming they had spotted the new moon for the month of Teshrai. Although the next night it was nowhere to be seen, he accepted their "for how can one testify that a woman gave birth, yet the next day she was seen still pregnant".  When [[Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya|Rabbi Yehoshua]] agreed with Rabbi Dosa, Rabban Gamliel felt the still fragile 'post Temple destruction' leadership was at risk of splintering. He decreed upon Rabbi Yehshua to come before him on Yom Kippor, as it came out according to his calculations and desecrate it by carrying his money and walking stick.  
+
Once two witnesses testified before Raban Gamliel that they had seen the new moon for the month of Teshrai, yet the next night it was nowhere to be seen and he accepted their testimony. Rabbi Dosa ben Harkinas argued saying there were surely false witnesses for how can one testify that a woman gave birth, yet the next day she was seen still pregnant.  When [[Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya|Rabbi Yehoshua]] agreed with Rabbi Dosa, Rabban Gamliel felt that the still fragile post Temple destruction leadership was at risk of splintering. He decreed upon Rabbi Yehshua to come before him on Yom Kippor as it came out according to his calculations and desecrate it by carying his money and walking stick.  
  
Rabbi Yehshua came to Rabbi Dosa who advised him to listen to Rabban Gamliel bringing proof from the members of [[Moshe Rabbenu|Moshe's]] Beit Din, whose names are not mentioned in the Torah. This comes to teach us that the Beis Din of each generation is equivalent to Moshe's. Meaning, had it mentioned the members names, one could argue that any later judges were of lesser stature, however since they remain unidentified, it can be argued that they are equivalent. Therefore if one debates the rulings of Rabban Gamliel's Beit Din, one should debate the rulings of each Bais Din that stood since the days of Moshe. Rabbi Yehushua accepted his advice and subdued himself in front of Rabban Gamliel.
+
Rabbi Yehshua came to Rabbi Dosa who advised him to listen to Rabban Gamliel. Since it does not mention the names of the members of [[Moshe Rabbenu|Moshe's]] Beit Din in the Torah it comes to teach us that the Beis Din of each generation is equivalent to Moshe's. Meaning; had it mentioned the members names, one could argue that any later judges were of lesser stature, however since they remain unnamed it is possible that they are equivalent. Therefore if one debates the rulings of Rabban Gamliel's Beit Din, one should debate the rulings of each Bais Din that stood since the days of Moshe. Rabbi Yehushua accepted his advice and subdued himself in front of Rabban Gamliel.
  
 
==Teachings==
 
==Teachings==
Line 38: Line 38:
 
File:00000205 beit knesset shem and ever tzfat.jpg
 
File:00000205 beit knesset shem and ever tzfat.jpg
 
File:00000202 door cave of shem and ever.jpg
 
File:00000202 door cave of shem and ever.jpg
File:00001455 doors shem and ever cave.jpg
+
 
File:00001456 courtyard shem vever tzfat.jpg
+
 
</gallery>
 
</gallery>
  

By adding content or making edits to this page you are agreeing to give full, complete and permanent rights of this content to Zissil.com. You are also verifying that this is unique content that has not been copied from any other source and is not copyright protected.

Cancel | Editing help (opens in new window)

Templates used on this page:

 
PrivacyDisclaimer Terms of Use
Share |
Share |
 
Personal tools
Namespaces
Variants
Actions
ZissilSidebarMenu
Navigation
Toolbox